The Maine Senate race just got its first real measurement since the Democratic field reshuffled itself, and the number will not comfort Republicans.
A new poll from the University of New Hampshire Survey Center gives Troy Jackson 49% support among likely voters, with Sen. Susan Collins at 46%. Another 5% said they were undecided or planning to back someone else.
Three points, with a margin of error of plus or minus 2.8 points. That’s a statistical tie with a lean, not a lead anyone should bank on.
How the Poll Was Conducted
The survey collected responses from 1,236 Maine residents between July 15 and July 20. It landed at a useful moment, overlapping with the county caucuses that effectively settled the Democratic nomination.
How Jackson Got Here
This race looked very different a month ago.
Graham Platner won the Democratic primary in June. He exited on July 8 following an allegation of sexual assault, which he has denied. That withdrawal blew the field wide open.
At one stage more than a dozen candidates had filed to replace him. Then Jackson, a former lawmaker and past president of the Maine Senate, dominated the county caucuses where convention delegates were chosen. His main rivals dropped out over the weekend that followed.
He is expected to formally secure the nomination at a convention Saturday.
The poll captured that consolidation in progress. Among Democrats who voted in the June primary:
- 51% wanted Jackson as the nominee
- 26% preferred Nirav Shah
- 11% preferred Shenna Bellows
That’s not a narrow win inside the party. That’s a clear preference.
The Favorability Problem for Collins
The head-to-head number is close. The underlying image numbers are not.
Collins is viewed favorably by 35% of Mainers surveyed and unfavorably by 53%. Jackson sits at 37% favorable and 32% unfavorable.
There’s a second detail worth pulling out. Fifteen percent of respondents said they don’t know enough about Jackson to form an opinion, while fewer than 1% said the same about Collins.
That asymmetry cuts both ways.
Jackson still has room to grow, because a meaningful slice of the electorate hasn’t formed a view of him. Collins has almost none, because after five terms, virtually every voter in Maine has already decided how they feel about her. She cannot reintroduce herself. She can only try to define her opponent before he defines himself.
Expect an enormous amount of advertising aimed at that 15%.
Collins Still Has Her Signature Strength
One number in the survey shows why writing Collins off would be premature.
A majority of Mainers, 53%, rate her as good or very good at securing federal dollars for the state. That has been the core of her political identity for decades, and it’s the argument that has kept her in office through cycles where the national environment ran against Republicans.
The question is whether delivering for Maine still outweighs party affiliation for enough voters in a nationalized election.
Why the Country Is Watching
This contest is on track to become one of the most expensive and closely followed Senate races in the country.
Democrats view Collins, a five-term incumbent, as genuinely vulnerable and see her seat as a critical pickup in their effort to take control of the Senate. Maine’s tendency toward split-ticket voting makes it one of the few places where a Republican senator can survive in a state that often votes Democratic at the top of the ballot.
If Collins holds, the Republican path to keeping the chamber gets substantially easier. If she loses, one of the last genuinely competitive statewide Republican operations in New England goes with her.
The Governor’s Race Looks Settled
The same survey tested the race for governor, and the picture there is far less suspenseful.
Democrat Hannah Pingree leads with 49% among likely voters. Republican Bobby Charles draws 35%, and independent Rick Bennett takes 6%. One percent backed another candidate and 8% remain undecided.
Those figures closely track a June survey from the New York Times, Portland Press Herald and Siena University, which found Pingree at 50%, Charles at 36% and Bennett at 8%.
Two independent polls arriving at nearly identical results is a strong signal. Barring something unexpected, that race appears to have a clear favorite.
What to Watch From Here
A few things will determine whether this three-point margin holds, grows or reverses.
The first is Jackson’s introduction to the general electorate. He is well known in Democratic circles and among voters who follow state politics, but a chunk of Mainers are meeting him for the first time. Whichever campaign shapes that first impression gains real ground.
The second is whether Collins can separate herself from national Republican politics. Her survival has always depended on being evaluated as an individual rather than as a party member. That’s harder in a midterm year with high political temperature.
The third is turnout. Maine draws unusually engaged voters and has a large independent bloc that resists easy prediction.
The convention Saturday makes Jackson’s nomination official. After that, roughly three and a half months of one of the most consequential Senate campaigns in the country.
Right now it’s a coin flip with a slight tilt. That’s exactly where both parties expected it to be.
Author
-
Lucienne Albrecht is Luxe Chronicle’s wealth and lifestyle editor, celebrated for her elegant perspective on finance, legacy, and global luxury culture. With a flair for blending sophistication with insight, she brings a distinctly feminine voice to the world of high society and wealth.






